IDisposable ownership semantics

This is primarily a question regarding whether or not C# has introduced any sort of syntactic sugar or support for a "nicer" way of expressing transfer of ownership.

For the purposes of this question, nullable types is fully enabled and static analysis that will issue

CA2000

CA2000

as an error is also turned on.

Consider a method that returns a type that implements

IDisposable

IDisposable

and needs to either return it, or ensure it gets

Dispose

Dispose

'd if an exception occurs - Currently I'd write something like this:

public SomeDisposable getDisposable() {
  var result = new SomeDisposable();
  try {
    //do possibly exception-throwing stuff here
    var ret = result;
    result = null;
    return ret;
  } finally {
    result?.Dispose();
  }
}

public SomeDisposable getDisposable() {
  var result = new SomeDisposable();
  try {
    //do possibly exception-throwing stuff here
    var ret = result;
    result = null;
    return ret;
  } finally {
    result?.Dispose();
  }
}

Is there anything better than this? This sort of pattern feels about as manual as

malloc

malloc

and

free

free

in C.

C#•17mo ago•

27 replies

Olipro

IDisposable ownership semantics

CA2000

CA2000

as an error is also turned on.

Consider a method that returns a type that implements

IDisposable

IDisposable

and needs to either return it, or ensure it gets

Dispose

Dispose

'd if an exception occurs - Currently I'd write something like this:

public SomeDisposable getDisposable() {
  var result = new SomeDisposable();
  try {
    //do possibly exception-throwing stuff here
    var ret = result;
    result = null;
    return ret;
  } finally {
    result?.Dispose();
  }
}

public SomeDisposable getDisposable() {
  var result = new SomeDisposable();
  try {
    //do possibly exception-throwing stuff here
    var ret = result;
    result = null;
    return ret;
  } finally {
    result?.Dispose();
  }
}

Is there anything better than this? This sort of pattern feels about as manual as

malloc

malloc

and

free

free

in C.

IDisposable ownership semantics

Similar Threads

IDisposable ownership semantics

Similar Threads

Similar Threads

Similar Threads