Sapphire - Imagine a Framework•3mo ago

Reduce loading time of ApplicationCommandRegistries

Hello all, I am experiencing a non-issue where the application command registries are taking over a minute to load. This is consistent, so I'm curious if there is any way to reduce this loading time. The bot has around 16 commands, most with minimal to no options.

[INFO] ApplicationCommandRegistries: Initializing...
[INFO] ApplicationCommandRegistries: Took 61,304ms to initialize.

[INFO] ApplicationCommandRegistries: Initializing...
[INFO] ApplicationCommandRegistries: Took 61,304ms to initialize.

22 Replies

Seren_Modz 21•3mo ago

you could change your default registry behaviour to bulk overwrite instead of having it compare each command for differences (i think that is the default, i can't remember).

import { ApplicationCommandRegistries, RegisterBehavior } from "@sapphire/framework";

// execute this before starting your bot
ApplicationCommandRegistries.setDefaultBehaviorWhenNotIdentical(RegisterBehavior.BulkOverwrite);

import { ApplicationCommandRegistries, RegisterBehavior } from "@sapphire/framework";

// execute this before starting your bot
ApplicationCommandRegistries.setDefaultBehaviorWhenNotIdentical(RegisterBehavior.BulkOverwrite);

https://www.sapphirejs.dev/docs/Guide/commands/application-commands/application-command-registry/advanced/setting-global-behavior-when-not-identical

Sapphire Framework

Configuring the global behavior when commands are not identical | S...

Configuring the global behavior is easy! You just need to import the

alaninnovates, the sequelOP•3mo ago

when i do development, i often start and restart the bot. if i ewre to use that, would there be negative impacts (i.e. ratelimits) if i were to do it too often?

Seren_Modz 21•3mo ago

i've never had any problems with it myself but i don't think i really restart my bot that much during dev

Favna•3mo ago

Sounds like a network issue tbh...

alaninnovates, the sequelOP•3mo ago

hm?

Favna•3mo ago

could still be ping to the discord server but still weird. short of using bluk overwrite I think the only thing we can realistically do for you here is if you share each and every command registration code bit, or preferebly the whole code base so @vladdy (who wrote all the diffing loging) can analyze it

vladdy•3mo ago

if you use bulkoverwrite, the time comes from discord unfortunately, not us. for non-overwrite... use VerboseOverwrite to see whats taking longer but I doubt we can do much

alaninnovates, the sequelOP•3mo ago

aha. i have found the issue. for every load, sapphire attempts to update every command because:

[DEBUG] ApplicationCommandRegistry[memory-match] Found differences for command "memory-match" (1395414702594723983) versus provided api data.
 └── At path: integrationTypes
     ├── Received: integration types present
     └── Expected: no integration types present

[DEBUG] ApplicationCommandRegistry[memory-match] Found differences for command "memory-match" (1395414702594723983) versus provided api data.
 └── At path: integrationTypes
     ├── Received: integration types present
     └── Expected: no integration types present

so i went through and added integration types to all of my commands. it now takes 3-4ms.

Favna•3mo ago

huh I thought you fixed integration types long ago @vladdy

vladdy•3mo ago

i thought so too :dead:

alaninnovates, the sequelOP•3mo ago

packages:

        "@sapphire/decorators": "^6.2.0",
        "@sapphire/discord.js-utilities": "^7.3.3",
        "@sapphire/framework": "^5.3.6",
        "@sapphire/plugin-scheduled-tasks": "^10.0.3",
        "@sapphire/utilities": "^3.18.2",
        "common-tags": "^1.8.2",
        "discord.js": "^14.21.0",
        "dotenv": "^17.2.0",
        "mongodb": "^6.17.0"

        "@sapphire/decorators": "^6.2.0",
        "@sapphire/discord.js-utilities": "^7.3.3",
        "@sapphire/framework": "^5.3.6",
        "@sapphire/plugin-scheduled-tasks": "^10.0.3",
        "@sapphire/utilities": "^3.18.2",
        "common-tags": "^1.8.2",
        "discord.js": "^14.21.0",
        "dotenv": "^17.2.0",
        "mongodb": "^6.17.0"

i think im on latest lmk if im not 🙃

vladdy•3mo ago

No you definitely have it right and yeah there's code for it so I dont understand why Can you share the command pls

alaninnovates, the sequelOP•3mo ago

all of them

alaninnovates, the sequelOP•3mo ago

message.txt

vladdy•3mo ago

Nah just one thats throwing this error, and I only need the registerApplicationCommands method

alaninnovates, the sequelOP•3mo ago

all of them are throwing this error

vladdy•3mo ago

then the simplest one that throws this error pls :Prayge:

alaninnovates, the sequelOP•3mo ago

but i guess uh the help command ‼️

import { ApplyOptions } from '@sapphire/decorators';
import { Command } from '@sapphire/framework';
import {
    ActionRowBuilder,
    ApplicationIntegrationType,
    ButtonBuilder,
    ButtonStyle,
    StringSelectMenuBuilder,
} from 'discord.js';
import { menuData, pages } from '../lib/help/pages';

@ApplyOptions<Command.Options>({
    name: 'help',
    description: 'Get help with the bot',
})
export class HelpCommand extends Command {
    public override registerApplicationCommands(registry: Command.Registry) {
        registry.registerChatInputCommand(
            (builder) =>
                builder
                    .setName(this.name)
                    .setDescription(this.description)
            {
                idHints: ['1393749717485355051'],
            },
        );
    }

    public override async chatInputRun(
        interaction: Command.ChatInputCommandInteraction,
    ) {
        await interaction.reply({
/* snip */
        });
    }
}

import { ApplyOptions } from '@sapphire/decorators';
import { Command } from '@sapphire/framework';
import {
    ActionRowBuilder,
    ApplicationIntegrationType,
    ButtonBuilder,
    ButtonStyle,
    StringSelectMenuBuilder,
} from 'discord.js';
import { menuData, pages } from '../lib/help/pages';

@ApplyOptions<Command.Options>({
    name: 'help',
    description: 'Get help with the bot',
})
export class HelpCommand extends Command {
    public override registerApplicationCommands(registry: Command.Registry) {
        registry.registerChatInputCommand(
            (builder) =>
                builder
                    .setName(this.name)
                    .setDescription(this.description)
            {
                idHints: ['1393749717485355051'],
            },
        );
    }

    public override async chatInputRun(
        interaction: Command.ChatInputCommandInteraction,
    ) {
        await interaction.reply({
/* snip */
        });
    }
}

vladdy•3mo ago

fun, ty

alaninnovates, the sequelOP•3mo ago

to fix i simply added

                    .setIntegrationTypes(
                        ApplicationIntegrationType.GuildInstall,
                    ),

                    .setIntegrationTypes(
                        ApplicationIntegrationType.GuildInstall,
                    ),

vladdy•3mo ago

i'll investigate tomorrow

alaninnovates, the sequelOP•3mo ago

tysm

Gaming

Programming

Reduce loading time of ApplicationCommandRegistries

Did you find this page helpful?