14 replies

Multi-account Discord: bot-to-bot replies generated but not delivered to Discord

Setup:
• Two Discord bot accounts (gary-discord and perry-discord) in one gateway
• Each bound to a different agent via bindings (with guildId)
• allowBots: true set at channels.discord level
• Both bots in the same guild, same text channel
• requireMention: true on the guild
What works:

• Both bots log in and receive messages
• Human @mentions trigger responses that post to Discord correctly
• Slash commands work
• allowBots: true is respected - when Bot A @mentions Bot B, Bot B's agent processes the message and generates a full response
What breaks:

• Bot B's response to Bot A's @mention never gets delivered to Discord
• The response shows in gateway logs as [agent:nested] session=agent:perry:discord:channel:... channel=webchat - it generates but routes to webchat instead of Discord
• No error in gateway.err.log - the delivery fails silently
• The first round (human triggers bot, bot posts to Discord) works. The second round (bot triggers bot via @mention, response generated but not posted) fails silently.
Logs showing the issue:

20:41:45 [agent:nested] session=agent:perry:discord:channel:1469065180028604456 ... channel=webchat  <-- Perry posts (this one DID reach Discord)
20:42:01 [agent:nested] session=agent:gary:discord:channel:1469065180028604456 ... channel=webchat  <-- Gary responds to Perry (NEVER reached Discord)
20:42:08 [agent:nested] session=agent:perry:discord:channel:1469065180028604456 ... channel=webchat REPLY_SKIPEarlier related error (before config fix):

[tools] message failed: Discord bot token missing for account "default"
[tools] message failed: guildId requiredThese were fixed by removing the empty default token and adding guildId to bindings. But even after those fixes, the silent delivery failure persists.

Config (relevant parts):

{
  "channels": {
    "discord": {
      "allowBots": true,
      "groupPolicy": "allowlist",
      "guilds": {
        "1469059651269165183": {
          "slug": "agent-hq",
          "requireMention": true,
          "users": ["373640790905454592"],
          "channels": { "*": { "allow": true, "requireMention": true } }
        }
      },
      "accounts": {
        "gary-discord": { "name": "Gary", "token": "..." },
        "perry-discord": { "name": "Perry", "token": "..." }
      }
    }
  },
  "bindings": [
    { "agentId": "gary", "match": { "channel": "discord", "accountId": "gary-discord", "guildId": "1469059651269165183" } },
    { "agentId": "perry", "match": { "channel": "discord", "accountId": "perry-discord", "guildId": "1469059651269165183" } }
  ]
}

20:41:45 [agent:nested] session=agent:perry:discord:channel:1469065180028604456 ... channel=webchat  <-- Perry posts (this one DID reach Discord)
20:42:01 [agent:nested] session=agent:gary:discord:channel:1469065180028604456 ... channel=webchat  <-- Gary responds to Perry (NEVER reached Discord)
20:42:08 [agent:nested] session=agent:perry:discord:channel:1469065180028604456 ... channel=webchat REPLY_SKIPEarlier related error (before config fix):

[tools] message failed: Discord bot token missing for account "default"
[tools] message failed: guildId requiredThese were fixed by removing the empty default token and adding guildId to bindings. But even after those fixes, the silent delivery failure persists.

Config (relevant parts):

{
  "channels": {
    "discord": {
      "allowBots": true,
      "groupPolicy": "allowlist",
      "guilds": {
        "1469059651269165183": {
          "slug": "agent-hq",
          "requireMention": true,
          "users": ["373640790905454592"],
          "channels": { "*": { "allow": true, "requireMention": true } }
        }
      },
      "accounts": {
        "gary-discord": { "name": "Gary", "token": "..." },
        "perry-discord": { "name": "Perry", "token": "..." }
      }
    }
  },
  "bindings": [
    { "agentId": "gary", "match": { "channel": "discord", "accountId": "gary-discord", "guildId": "1469059651269165183" } },
    { "agentId": "perry", "match": { "channel": "discord", "accountId": "perry-discord", "guildId": "1469059651269165183" } }
  ]
}

Question: Is multi-account Discord bot-to-bot reply delivery supported? The inbound path works (bot messages are received and processed), but the outbound path silently drops replies when the triggering message came from another bot account in the same gateway. Is there a config fix, or is this a known limitation? @Krill 🦐

FotC�

Friends of the Crustacean 🦞🤝•6d ago•

14 replies

toli

Multi-account Discord: bot-to-bot replies generated but not delivered to Discord

20:41:45 [agent:nested] session=agent:perry:discord:channel:1469065180028604456 ... channel=webchat  <-- Perry posts (this one DID reach Discord)
20:42:01 [agent:nested] session=agent:gary:discord:channel:1469065180028604456 ... channel=webchat  <-- Gary responds to Perry (NEVER reached Discord)
20:42:08 [agent:nested] session=agent:perry:discord:channel:1469065180028604456 ... channel=webchat REPLY_SKIPEarlier related error (before config fix):

[tools] message failed: Discord bot token missing for account "default"
[tools] message failed: guildId requiredThese were fixed by removing the empty default token and adding guildId to bindings. But even after those fixes, the silent delivery failure persists.

Config (relevant parts):

{
  "channels": {
    "discord": {
      "allowBots": true,
      "groupPolicy": "allowlist",
      "guilds": {
        "1469059651269165183": {
          "slug": "agent-hq",
          "requireMention": true,
          "users": ["373640790905454592"],
          "channels": { "*": { "allow": true, "requireMention": true } }
        }
      },
      "accounts": {
        "gary-discord": { "name": "Gary", "token": "..." },
        "perry-discord": { "name": "Perry", "token": "..." }
      }
    }
  },
  "bindings": [
    { "agentId": "gary", "match": { "channel": "discord", "accountId": "gary-discord", "guildId": "1469059651269165183" } },
    { "agentId": "perry", "match": { "channel": "discord", "accountId": "perry-discord", "guildId": "1469059651269165183" } }
  ]
}

20:41:45 [agent:nested] session=agent:perry:discord:channel:1469065180028604456 ... channel=webchat  <-- Perry posts (this one DID reach Discord)
20:42:01 [agent:nested] session=agent:gary:discord:channel:1469065180028604456 ... channel=webchat  <-- Gary responds to Perry (NEVER reached Discord)
20:42:08 [agent:nested] session=agent:perry:discord:channel:1469065180028604456 ... channel=webchat REPLY_SKIPEarlier related error (before config fix):

[tools] message failed: Discord bot token missing for account "default"
[tools] message failed: guildId requiredThese were fixed by removing the empty default token and adding guildId to bindings. But even after those fixes, the silent delivery failure persists.

Config (relevant parts):

{
  "channels": {
    "discord": {
      "allowBots": true,
      "groupPolicy": "allowlist",
      "guilds": {
        "1469059651269165183": {
          "slug": "agent-hq",
          "requireMention": true,
          "users": ["373640790905454592"],
          "channels": { "*": { "allow": true, "requireMention": true } }
        }
      },
      "accounts": {
        "gary-discord": { "name": "Gary", "token": "..." },
        "perry-discord": { "name": "Perry", "token": "..." }
      }
    }
  },
  "bindings": [
    { "agentId": "gary", "match": { "channel": "discord", "accountId": "gary-discord", "guildId": "1469059651269165183" } },
    { "agentId": "perry", "match": { "channel": "discord", "accountId": "perry-discord", "guildId": "1469059651269165183" } }
  ]
}

Multi-account Discord: bot-to-bot replies generated but not delivered to Discord

Multi-account Discord: bot-to-bot replies generated but not delivered to Discord

Similar Threads

Similar Threads

Similar Threads