How should I structure runtimes and service dependencies in my app with @effect-atom/atom-react??
effect✅Solved!
How should I structure runtimes and service dependencies in my app?
I'm working on an app architecture and trying to understand the best practices for composing services and managing runtimes in Effect.
Context: - I have an
AuthService
AuthService
and a
SignInPageService
SignInPageService
-
SignInPageService
SignInPageService
depends on
AuthService
AuthService
My Questions:
1. Service dependency declaration What's the practical difference between declaring dependencies in the service definition vs. providing them at runtime?
// Option B: Provide dependency when creating runtimeconst runtime = Atom.runtime(get => SignInPageService.Default.pipe( Layer.provideMerge(AuthService.runtime.layer) ))
// Option B: Provide dependency when creating runtimeconst runtime = Atom.runtime(get => SignInPageService.Default.pipe( Layer.provideMerge(AuthService.runtime.layer) ))
2. Runtime granularity Should I create: - One runtime per module/feature? - One runtime per service? - One runtime per component? - A single app-level runtime?
Additional context:
// Also seen this pattern - how does it differ?const runtime = Atom.runtime(SignInPageService.Default)
// Also seen this pattern - how does it differ?const runtime = Atom.runtime(SignInPageService.Default)
I want to understand the architectural implications of each approach, especially regarding: - Service lifecycle management - Dependency resolution - Testing isolation - Performance considerations
Any guidance on best practices would be appreciated!