Which of these used dress shoes would you go with?

Looking for some black shoes for a wedding as a groomsman, and I'd like to buy used. Between these three, which seem best in terms of condition? I don't have enough experience to tell what can/can't be fixed with some reconditioning or polish. It's probably easiest to refer to them by their backgrounds - white vs grass vs grey wood background. Thanks!
s-l1600.png
s-l1600.png
s-l1600.png
Was this page helpful?