How bad is this proper cloth shirt?

Part fit check, part advice. I had this shirt remade a few times and I want to like proper cloth but every shirt from them just feels off. I want to see if others have similar opinions or maybe I'm just nit picking. To me it feels like the waist is oversized while the sleeves, shoulder, chest are slim fit. I'm not sure this can be altered to fit the way I want and I'm not sure of better options at a similar price point in NYC. Note: I'm about 5'5, and carry weight on my stomach/have narrow shoulders. A lot of off the rack items aren't a great fit either.
No description
No description
No description
No description
7 Replies
sharloy
sharloy9mo ago
Shoulders are a little small. I don’t think waist is too big. I would see how an oversized look would look on you next
TMNY
TMNY9mo ago
Trying to give some reference. One hand is where my body ends. If I pull the shirt away from my body the length of my hand (wrist to tip of index finger) is how much extra fabric exists in the stomach
No description
Erik
Erik9mo ago
It looks like the shoulder seam sits right where it should actually Unless you want the oversized look
awburkey
awburkey9mo ago
I agree with charli. I think a little bit more space in the shoulders would be nice. I think having some fabric at the waist is fine and makes stuff easier to wear and move in personally
TMNY
TMNY9mo ago
It fails the hug test
Erik
Erik9mo ago
sanchoe
drew-fc
drew-fc8mo ago
Did you get sized by them IRL? I'd go back there and complain till they get it right I had to have multiple remakes and multiple in person visits But once it's dialed in, P.C. is really nice