Looking for opinions on groomsmen tie color for my wedding

Our wedding colors are green+gold. It's an outdoor wedding, early October, mid-day, out in the woods. All groomsmen and myself will be in medium-grey suits and white shirt. I'll be wearing a grenadine green tie (https://www.kentwang.com/accessories/ties/grenadine-green.html) and would like to order my groomsmen something complimentary. I ordered them all this green "grenalux" tie https://www.thetiebar.com/product/tie-5129-0185?srsltid=AfmBOorgllf9QgYak8jXVlfIcYmglXW5KSY0Esp9V12jRxme5k9z8fLh but am honestly not a huge fan now that I have them in hand. It's kind of close to my tie, but noticeably different, in a way that clashes instead of compliments.

My thought is to instead get them a totally different color, either a sage green (https://www.thetiebar.com/product/tie-5129-0301) or a champagne (https://www.thetiebar.com/product/tie-4735-0205?variant=30518sk). My budget doesn't allow for more than ~25 bucks a tie, so I'll have to get some lower quality ones from the tie bar, etsy, etc.

How do y'all think the sage and/or champagne will look with the medium grey suits, white shirts and white/green boutonniere? I'm leaning toward the champagne, but am open to and hoping for feedback and suggestions.
Add the Grenalux Hunter Green Tie to your wardrobe today.
One of this year's most popular wedding colors meets up with our bestselling tie style.
Add the Bhldn Union Solid Light Champagne Tie to your wardrobe today.
Was this page helpful?