Help me pick between these two AE loafers?

Hey guys Need help deciding between the AE Randolph and the new AE Newman The Newman has a beefroll style that I like, but I'm hearing it's made in India and has a very plasticky feel to it The Randolphs I'm hearing is a classic, with at least some of the construction process being done in USA, with a higher quality leather, my only concern is that maybe it's not a versatile loafer that can be dressed down? For context I'd be wearing this with trousers, knitted polos or camp collar shirts, or long sleeve linen shirts, tucked or untucked What do you guys think?