Can't deserialize datetime string from Postgres

I'm getting the following error:

Inconsistent column data: Conversion failed: expected a datetime string in column 'createdOn', found 2025-05-22 13:03:05.144-04

Inconsistent column data: Conversion failed: expected a datetime string in column 'createdOn', found 2025-05-22 13:03:05.144-04

I can correctly read the value with

node-postgres

node-postgres

and Jetbrains DataGrip. I tried to install Postgres 17 both with Homebrew and Postgres.app.
I've confirmed that the

DateStyle

DateStyle

setting is set to the default (ISO, MDY)

I'm using Prisma 6.5