Southern Star Trails
FE team, how do I debate the accounts of being able to see the same southern stars in both Australia and South America at the same time. And that they apparently rotate around a center point like the north ? I see these being brought up in a lot of debates but the FE answer hasn’t been clear to me. Thanks #flat-earth-questions
4 Replies
First of all you don't have to account for the stars as they are non sequitur.
Secondly it's not "at the same time" as that would mean it's night at the same time for those places and it's not.
Thirdly not being able to say or figure out how something works doesn't mean it can't work. Just because someone doesn't know how is an "argument from incredulity"
You cannot be in australia and south america at the same time so there is no way you can see the same stars in the same directional sky from those locations. The claim is that the same direction in the sky from two different perspective locations. The stars maybe able to be seen from both locations but one may have to look due east at one location and due west in the other. The same stars claim is just that. It's a claim. They need to prove which direction the stars are being viewed in each location. If they don't. It's a story not worth entertaining. Realize that when you move from the sink area of your kitchen to the dining room, the ceiling looks different for each location. Your question is fatally flawed so try not to ask anymore fatally flawed questions.
Ask them for the livestreams of their claims :pogcorn:
Earth measures flat below the star trails.
