The domain Foo.Bar requires that an actor is provided at all times and none was provided.

Noticed this when running tests against latest main. We have our domains set up like:

  authorization do
    authorize :by_default
    require_actor? true
  end

  authorization do
    authorize :by_default
    require_actor? true
  end

And when we're using authorize?: false, like in tests, we'd also pass actor: nil to not have errors. But now on main, it looks like actor: nil is throwing forbidden errors with this config where it didn't before:

     ** (Ash.Error.Forbidden)
     Bread Crumbs:
       > Exception raised in: Foo.Bar.read

     Forbidden Error

     ** (Ash.Error.Forbidden)
     Bread Crumbs:
       > Exception raised in: Foo.Bar.read

     Forbidden Error

Do you know if this change was intentional or not?

Solution:

just pushed to main

Jump to solution

10 Replies

ZachDaniel•6mo ago

not intentional, looking into it

Solution

ZachDaniel•6mo ago

just pushed to main

pikdumOP•6mo ago

cool, testing now i'm looking forward to elixir 1.19's compilation speed improvements, lol our app takes a pretty long time to compile all the dependencies still seeing forbidden errors, but slightly different stacktrace than before

ZachDaniel•6mo ago

🤔 interesting.

pikdumOP•6mo ago

message.txt

pikdumOP•6mo ago

think this test is going through AshJsonApi somehow?, let me verify it still happens with main of that yep

ZachDaniel•6mo ago

🤔 "(ash 3.5.15) lib/ash/policy/check/expression.ex:3: Ash.Policy.Check.Expression.check/4", that is surprising... what data layer are you using?

pikdumOP•6mo ago

AshPostgres.DataLayer we do have some simple checks with access_type :runtime on read, it looks like let me double check i'm actually on latest main

ZachDaniel•6mo ago

okay 🤔

pikdumOP•6mo ago

blah, yeah i was locked on the previous commit can confirm it's fixed with https://github.com/ash-project/ash/commit/34193cb1eb4c11ae28a514182094d7da0e187467 all tests passing thanks!

Gaming

Programming

The domain Foo.Bar requires that an actor is provided at all times and none was provided.

Did you find this page helpful?