C#•3y ago

❔ Where should the CQRS be in the Clean Architecture?

Hello guys, hope you're doing well,
Please if I want to work with

Clean Architecture

Clean Architecture

Clean Architecture

Clean Architecture and I want to use

CQRS

CQRS

CQRS

CQRS, fromm your experience, should the

Commands

Commands

Commands

Commands and

Queries

Queries

Queries

Queries be in the

App

App

App

App layer or should the

CQRS components

CQRS components

CQRS components

CQRS components be separated in another layer ?

Thanks in advance :)

Cracker•3/4/23, 5:55 PM

I would separate data access methods to its own class library, there it can be referenced and used from other projects if added in future

Cracker•3/4/23, 5:56 PM

X.Common.Application (common data transfer objects and enums)
X.Service.Application (business logic)
X.Entity.Application (data access)

jcotton42•3/5/23, 6:35 AM

What's even the appeal of clean architecture?
I see so many questions about "where does X go?"

iskepes•3/5/23, 8:34 AM

I guess it depends how tightly you want the cqrs want to be in your application? If its the one and only communication method (or principle, however you call it) (im guessing it will be) then I'd put it somewhere near the "core" which means application layer in your case, then, it depends whether you will be reusing those models in some other applications, if so, you should separate them so you can publish nugets of them, if not then I'd say they would happily live in Application layer

Jjcotton42 What's even the appeal of clean architecture? I see so many questions about "whe...

iskepes•3/5/23, 8:36 AM

It could be a bit hard to grasp at first, kinda like ddd, but I believe it has its place, maybe not in small apps. What kind of architecture appeals to you?

jcotton42•3/5/23, 8:36 AM

something akin to vertical slice is what I arrive at in my personal projects

jcotton42•3/5/23, 8:36 AM

CA just seems like an enormous amount of ceremony for little benefit

Accord•3/6/23, 8:43 AM

Was this issue resolved? If so, run

/close

/close

otherwise I will mark this as stale and this post will be archived until there is new activity.

❔ Where should the CQRS be in the Clean Architecture?

Similar Threads

Similar Threads

Similar Threads