Cloudflare Developers•3y ago

You can do that if you want. We just don’t recommend it.

Matt SilverlockOP•3/9/23, 1:28 AM

R2 list() -> write keys to queue in sendBatch() -> paginate -> keep going. Store page state in a KV key or D1?

Jacob•3/9/23, 1:28 AM

Oh that could work. and then just keep hitting the endpoint until it pages through them all

Matt SilverlockOP•3/9/23, 1:29 AM

Call ack() when the copy succeeds or retry() to put it back on the queue

Matt SilverlockOP•3/9/23, 1:29 AM

In the consumer

Jacob•3/9/23, 1:29 AM

amazingggg I can't wait

I could use https://repeat.dev on a cron for pinging the list() worker to keep it all in the cloud too

repeat.dev | homepage

Create a webhook, schedule a task, forward emails, deploy in seconds. Everything in a simple web based editor.

Jacob•3/9/23, 1:30 AM

I'm curious to see how best to manage concurrency. Does it automatically scale down if you call retry() too much?

Matt SilverlockOP•3/9/23, 1:31 AM

Yeah and/or throw errors from your consumer

Matt SilverlockOP•3/9/23, 1:32 AM

The bottleneck is probably the copy calls vs the list

Matt SilverlockOP•3/9/23, 1:32 AM

Since copy will be blocking, IIRC, until the copy is done

Jacob•3/9/23, 1:32 AM

Yep - I can do up to 8x concurrency though which should help

MMatt Silverlock Yeah and/or throw errors from your consumer

Jacob•3/9/23, 1:33 AM

Cool - I definitely prefer to avoid erroring out the consumer whenever possible so retry() will work great

Matt SilverlockOP•3/9/23, 1:34 AM

Or ack() what you need and throw to force retry of anything you didn’t ack in that batch

Matt SilverlockOP•3/9/23, 1:34 AM

https://developers.cloudflare.com/queues/learning/batching-retries/#explicit-acknowledgement

Batching and Retries · Cloudflare Queues

When configuring a consumer Worker for a queue, you can also define how messages are batched as they are delivered.

Jacob•3/9/23, 1:35 AM

that works too. But throwing a global error to trigger behavior feels wrong haha

Matt SilverlockOP•3/9/23, 1:37 AM

#alwaysbethrowin

Jacob•3/9/23, 1:37 AM

that's nice that it behaves that way though for when you have an unexpected error

Jacob•3/9/23, 2:59 AM

What is the max size that a backlog can grow to?

Unsmart•3/9/23, 3:08 AM

there isnt a limit only way messages get removed is being processed or being older than 4 days

Unsmart•3/9/23, 3:09 AM

oh wait jk the backlog size is 25GB

Unsmart•3/9/23, 3:09 AM

interesting thats newly added to the limits page

Unsmart•3/9/23, 3:09 AM

I think

Jacob•3/9/23, 2:19 PM

Ahh thanks I missed that

JJacob That's awesome! Sadly this particular queue is just waiting on Discord rate limi...

Kai•3/14/23, 10:18 PM

Any chance you can share how you did this? I've still not figured out an efficient way to do something like this.

Kai•3/14/23, 10:20 PM

Also, unrelated, is there a chance we can get a sort of dynamic key as part of queues? There's still only one queue and one consumer script but batching & concurrency is done per-key?
Seems like an easy way to enable much more reuse. Creating a new queue for every log file that needs appending or for every API region etc. is annoying and feels unnecessary, they are all exact duplicates just with a different name to make them work in parallel

KKai Any chance you can share how you did this? I've still not figured out an efficie...

Jacob•3/14/23, 10:35 PM

It’s not terribly clever… I just watch for it to return headers saying it’s out of quota and await scheduler.wait() with whatever duration it gives in another header. Also sleeps if I get back a 429 (based on the retry_after value it sends.) I do a bit of extra sleeping after like 4x 429s in a short period to be nice, but it’s not entirely necessary.
Discord has good documentation for the rate limit headers and 429 responses it sends: https://discord.com/developers/docs/topics/rate-limits

Discord Developer Portal

Discord Developer Portal — API Docs for Bots and Developers

Integrate your service with Discord — whether it's a bot or a game or whatever your wildest imagination can come up with.

Kai•3/14/23, 10:36 PM

await scheduler.wait()

this is probably the bit I'm missing? what is that? Does that sleep but isn't billable / cause timeouts?

Jacob•3/14/23, 10:38 PM

Basically the same as the classic await new Promise(r => setTimeout(r, 2000)); AFAIK. You will get billed for that duration

Jacob•3/14/23, 10:38 PM

Discord only ever makes me wait like 2 seconds so I haven’t run into timeouts

Kai•3/14/23, 10:39 PM

ah ok :/ I have much tighter & complex rate limits and have so far failed to implement them on top of cloudflare without also paying a lot. Like 10k+ outstanding requests but only 200 / 1h allowed & any overrun disqualifies me from getting higher limits so

Jacob•3/14/23, 10:41 PM

Ahh yeah if it’s that tight then Queues might not work for you

Kai•3/14/23, 10:41 PM

yeah, but thanks for sharing anyways!

Jacob•3/14/23, 10:43 PM

Maybe you could specify the file it should append to in the Queue message? Each message you send is an object, so you could send something like {file: “log1.txt”, line: “my log line 123”}

Jacob•3/14/23, 10:43 PM

Then the consumer would check that field and append to that file

Kai•3/14/23, 10:43 PM

yeah but then the batching gets worse and worse the more files I funnel through that one

Jacob•3/14/23, 10:44 PM

Consumer concurrency is coming soon

Kai•3/14/23, 10:44 PM

Yeah, excited for that feature, but I don't see how that interacts with this

Jacob•3/14/23, 10:44 PM

Ohh sorry just understood what you meant

Jacob•3/14/23, 10:45 PM

I see so a batch has a mix of messages from all the different files, so you have more writes to your log storage

Jacob•3/14/23, 10:45 PM

Interesting use case. I wonder if there will be some kind of partitioning in the future

Kai•3/14/23, 10:45 PM

yeah and I have a bunch of essentially duplicated logic then + either have to use huge batch sizes and risk overrunning the time, or have smaller sizes, which may end up in unreasonably small write batches

Kai•3/14/23, 10:46 PM

I mean duplicating the queues has worked for me in the past but it makes the calling code more confusing then necessary, makes the dashboard worse and updating is annoying

Kai•3/14/23, 10:47 PM

I mean all this is solved on my side fairly easily with just a bit of TS magic & a few scripts but seems like a fairly easily thing to solve on the queues side

Kai•3/14/23, 10:47 PM

(even if I have to set the possible keys ahead of time & can't have too many, it'd still be so nice)

Kai•3/14/23, 10:49 PM

unfortunately I have no insight into what other people use queues for, but batching writes & rate limiting are the two big ones I've seen so far, and both would benefit from something there greatly

Unsmart•3/14/23, 10:54 PM

I don't think queues would be any good for rate limiting unless you mean reducing throughput to external apis

UUnsmart I don't think queues would be any good for rate limiting unless you mean reducin...

Jacob•3/14/23, 10:57 PM

That’s exactly what I’m doing

UUnsmart I don't think queues would be any good for rate limiting unless you mean reducin...

Kai•3/14/23, 11:54 PM

yeah that's also what I'm doing. I think (?) a fairly common need given cloudflare based products have no problem handing out request volumes that just kill vendors. Generally I've not seen that many external APIs disallow hitting the rate limit in general, but they'll get unhappy if it's too much / impacting other customers.

Kai•3/14/23, 11:55 PM

So at least taking some care to stop that from happening is important and queues seems like the best way to still ensure all requests make it eventually, but limit throughput. It's just a bit akward to implement efficiently right now

Erisa•3/14/23, 11:58 PM

you can also batch from a queue if the provider allows it, to avoid spending a request for each and better optimise the amount of data you send in each request (which i think jacob is doing?)

Jacob•3/15/23, 12:39 AM

Yes that’s what I’m doing to increase throughout - batching together data so I’m making fewer api calls

You can do that if you want. We just don’t recommend it.

Similar Threads

Similar Threads

Similar Threads