Which tuxedo option would you pick?

Any criteria you can think of applies! I just have a budget of around $500-600 and I've done the research on what style I want - the two linked below seem to be the best of what I can get; please let me know if you have other suggestions! I just know nothing about clothing quality, etc. and have more than a few black-tie weddings coming up. I have my own wedding, too - I'm wearing a peak lapel and I'd like to look different at the other weddings, so I'm going with the shawl collar. I like the black tux option, since I can go into Nordstrom, but if the Indochino quality is much better, I'd go with that. Which of these two would you choose? The Black Tux: https://buy.theblacktux.com/products/shawl-collar-tuxedo Indochino: https://www.indochino.com/product/highworth-black-tuxedo?queryId=8fd9f0065b3ab0e63c683104aaa4c319
The Black Tux - Buy New
Shawl Collar Tuxedo
Shawls aren't just for little old ladies. This shawl collar tux feels both fresh and classic perfect for when you want to stand out a little. Includes jacket and pants. Pants are available in classic and slim fits. 100% super-fine Italian merino wool One-button closure 100% silk satin shawl collar Side vents Fully canv
Highworth Black Tuxedo
Be a master of subtlety with the Highworth Black Tuxedo. This fabric's geometric diamond weave gives it a special texture and depth that's best seen up close. And trust us, they'll want to get close.
29 Replies
zerodarkwntrgrn
zerodarkwntrgrn8mo ago
A few more things to help: * in person is preferable, but online is fine. * I need it by May 17 * Second hand is fine * 5'11' 180lb with a little muffin top
tun🌻
tun🌻8mo ago
I don't know much about tuxes to actually give any help sorry but indochino being bad is such a common thing here that it has it's own sticker
zerodarkwntrgrn
zerodarkwntrgrn8mo ago
HAHAH well that crosses that one off the list - anything similar for black tux?
awburkey
awburkey8mo ago
ebay
zerodarkwntrgrn
zerodarkwntrgrn8mo ago
any specific brand you recommend searching for? or just "shawl tuxedo"?
Michael
Michael8mo ago
spier and mackay might be worth a look, though they're definitely on the upper end of your budget if you include alterations I don't think they have ready to wear shawl lapel tuxedos actually, but they offer them for MTO which starts at $673
zerodarkwntrgrn
zerodarkwntrgrn8mo ago
oh, beautiful thank you
Bigelow
Bigelow8mo ago
black tux also sucks
zerodarkwntrgrn
zerodarkwntrgrn8mo ago
Damn how so?
Bigelow
Bigelow8mo ago
cheap materials and construction, it's the same shit as your typical cheap suit rental places like men's wearhouse
zerodarkwntrgrn
zerodarkwntrgrn8mo ago
so best bet would be to get a high-quality, but used tux on ebay?
Bigelow
Bigelow8mo ago
they couldn't even get the fit right on their model, look at those shoulders
No description
Bigelow
Bigelow8mo ago
yeah. ebay is the way you gotta know your measurements though, so measure a suit jacket, sport coat, or blazer that fits you well and go off of that, if possible
zerodarkwntrgrn
zerodarkwntrgrn8mo ago
yeah I think I'm gonna go to a tailor to get measured
Bigelow
Bigelow8mo ago
honestly getting your body measurements is not as useful as knowing the measurements of clothing that fits you well when you're looking on ebay people will list "this jacket has 18" shoulders" not "this jacket will fit a person with 17" shoudlers" yknow
zerodarkwntrgrn
zerodarkwntrgrn8mo ago
ahh okay that makes sense I do have like 3 different size jackets - one's tailored but still
Bigelow
Bigelow8mo ago
if I were you I'd post em and get feedback on what fits the best like this then measure that and use those measurements to search on ebay
zerodarkwntrgrn
zerodarkwntrgrn8mo ago
word yeah I'll do that - I gotta get one of them tailored too then I'll do that If I just bought a jacket that’s high end, how hard would it be to find pants (in-person) to match or that look good?
Bigelow
Bigelow8mo ago
not recommended. buy as a set same goes for any suit
zerodarkwntrgrn
zerodarkwntrgrn8mo ago
Figured Thanks for the help!
HaveanA1day
HaveanA1day8mo ago
Is SuitSupply better?
awburkey
awburkey8mo ago
By light years
zerodarkwntrgrn
zerodarkwntrgrn8mo ago
@GSH @ll.beansandrice @Michael do you have thoughts on this? For $250 on eBay
No description
No description
No description
No description
Bigelow
Bigelow8mo ago
I'm not a tux expert so I'll defer to others' advice but I know Zegna makes good stuff. If you end up going for it I'd try to offer down to 200 or so
awburkey
awburkey8mo ago
Make sure the measurements are solid. A drop 7 is higher than normal
zerodarkwntrgrn
zerodarkwntrgrn8mo ago
The brand was on that list that Michael sent and the measurements do line up What is a drop 7? Oh I see
awburkey
awburkey8mo ago
It means the difference in jacket and pant size is 7. 6 is more typical
zerodarkwntrgrn
zerodarkwntrgrn8mo ago
Let me double check but the measurements for the pants seemed to line up too Says waist 34” with 3” to let out, I’m a 34 in normal jeans/khakis The measurements give room to tailor too Free return so I think I’m gonna pull the trigger
Want results from more Discord servers?
Add your server