© 2026 Hedgehog Software, LLC

TwitterGitHubDiscord
More
CommunitiesDocsAboutTermsPrivacy
Search
Star
Setup for Free
mfadm
mfad•16mo ago•
16 replies
djacs99

Secondhand Penny Loafers brands/things to look for

Hey everyone,
I'm looking to buy some secondhand penny loafers in either black or dark brown. I've searched through some Q and A posts on here previously to try and get a sense of some brands I can look for and some tips, but I wanted to get direct advice/feedback:

1. Looking for around $150 USD and below, this is somewhat flexible.
2. I'm in NYC so I have access to tri-state area brick and mortar stores, however I was primarily going to search on Ebay. (open to Depop/Grailed etc.)
3. This isn't urgent, I want to find a pair that are in good shape for my budget that will fit well so happy to spend a month or even more searching.

With that in mind, what are some brands I should be using in my searches, and what should I specifically look out for to see if the shoe is still in decent-good condition? Thank you!
mfad banner
mfadJoin
My Friends Are Dressin': A fashion community making clothing less intimidating and helping you develop your own style.
15,975Members
Resources

Similar Threads

Was this page helpful?
Recent Announcements

Similar Threads

Penny Loafers
mfadmmfad / questions-and-advice
3y ago
Secondhand Loafers
mfadmmfad / questions-and-advice
14mo ago
penny loafers vs tassel loafers
mfadmmfad / questions-and-advice
3y ago
wide feet penny loafers
mfadmmfad / questions-and-advice
3y ago