multiple modals how to be more efficient loading them
hi i have a site with many modals like login modal, register modal so on so forth. i put them in my default layout to be available everywhere is this the right approach. should i be using some kind of lazy loading or some strategy considering the modals aren't needed immediately usually and sometimes aren't used
11 Replies
Hi @WiFi Plug. I'm kapa.ai, your friendly support bot. I will try to answer your question by searching through the knowledge base. :wave:
----------------------
To efficiently handle multiple modals (like login, register, etc.) in a Nuxt app, especially when they aren't always needed immediately, you should consider lazy loading and delayed hydration strategies rather than including all modal components in your default layout.
Recommended strategies:
1. Lazy Loading with the
Do not include all modals in your default layout. Use the
<Lazy> Prefix
Nuxt auto-imports components and provides a Lazy prefix for components, which loads them only when needed. For example, use <LazyLoginModal /> instead of <LoginModal />. This reduces the initial JavaScript bundle size and improves performance, especially for components like modals that may not be used on every page load. However, note that lazy loading alone does not delay hydration—components are still hydrated as soon as they are rendered unless you use further strategies [Nuxt 3 Lazy Component Prefix].
2. Delayed (Lazy) Hydration
Nuxt supports delayed hydration, allowing you to control when a component becomes interactive. You can use hydration strategies such as:
- hydrate-on-visible: Hydrates the modal only when it becomes visible in the viewport.
- hydrate-on-idle: Hydrates when the browser is idle.
- hydrate-on-interaction: Hydrates after a user interaction (e.g., click, mouseover).
- hydrate-after: Hydrates after a specified delay.
- hydrate-when: Hydrates based on a boolean condition (e.g., when you open the modal).
Example for a login modal:
This ensures the modal is only hydrated (and thus interactive) when the user interacts with it, saving resources [Nuxt Docs: Delayed Hydration].
3. Programmatic Control with useOverlay
If you use Nuxt UI, the useOverlay composable allows you to programmatically create and open modals only when needed, further reducing unnecessary rendering and hydration [useOverlay composable].
4. Avoid Global Registration Unless Necessary
Placing all modals in your default layout means they are always present in the DOM, which can be inefficient. Instead, render and hydrate them only when needed using the strategies above.
---
Summary:Do not include all modals in your default layout. Use the
Lazy prefix and delayed hydration strategies to load and hydrate modals only when necessary. For even more control, use programmatic overlays. This approach will make your Nuxt app more efficient and performant [Nuxt Docs: Delayed Hydration] [useOverlay composable].
----------------------
Note: you can ask me a follow up question by @ mentioning me again :speech_balloon:
----------------------<@679734274840330384> Kapa.ai is still learning and improving, please let me know how I did by reacting below.
@kapa.ai so i have a pinia ui store which stores which modal is currently open if any and my modals listen to that to be opened or closed. i do use nuxt ui but is my approach correct as im a beginner. and if not putting the modals in my default layout then where can i initialise them? i thought i could use the lazy prefix as a good solution?
Let me check the knowledge base for you again. One moment! :books:
----------------------
Your approach of using a Pinia store to track which modal is open is a valid and common pattern for managing global UI state in Nuxt, especially when you want to control modal visibility from anywhere in your app. Nuxt is not opinionated about state management, and Pinia is the official Vue recommendation for global state [Nuxt State Management].
However, regarding where to initialize or render your modals:
- Placing all modals in the default layout is not the most efficient approach, especially if you have many modals that are rarely used. This can increase your initial page load and hydration cost.
- Using the
Instead of always including all modals in your layout, you can conditionally render them in your layout or a top-level component based on your Pinia store state. For example: This way, the modal component is only loaded and hydrated when needed. Summary:
- Your use of Pinia for modal state is correct. - Prefer conditional rendering with the
Lazy prefix (e.g., <LazyLoginModal />) is a good solution. It ensures that the modal component is only loaded when it is actually rendered, reducing the initial bundle size and improving performance.
Where to render modals:Instead of always including all modals in your layout, you can conditionally render them in your layout or a top-level component based on your Pinia store state. For example: This way, the modal component is only loaded and hydrated when needed. Summary:
- Your use of Pinia for modal state is correct. - Prefer conditional rendering with the
Lazy prefix for your modals, rather than always including them in the layout.
- You can still place the conditional modal rendering in your layout or a top-level component, but only render them when needed.
This approach is efficient and aligns with Nuxt best practices for performance and code-splitting [Nuxt Docs: Delayed Hydration].
----------------------
Note: you can ask me a follow up question by @ mentioning me again :speech_balloon:
----------------------<@679734274840330384> Kapa.ai is still learning and improving, please let me know how I did by reacting below.
so what does the conditional v-if achieve over using lazy? i thought lazy would only render when needed? as inside my register modal component for example i have "<template>
<!-- Use Nuxt UI Modal component -->
<!-- v-model controls visibility, bind directly to the Pinia store getter -->
<UModal v-model="uiStore.isRegisterModalOpen" prevent-close>"
@kapa.ai so what does the conditional v-if achieve over using lazy? i thought lazy would only render when needed? as inside my register modal component for example i have "<template>
<!-- Use Nuxt UI Modal component -->
<!-- v-model controls visibility, bind directly to the Pinia store getter -->
<UModal v-model="uiStore.isRegisterModalOpen" prevent-close>"
Let me check the knowledge base for you again. One moment! :books:
----------------------
Great question! The difference between using the
This tells Nuxt to code-split the component and only load its JavaScript when the component is rendered for the first time. However, if you always include
This ensures that the modal component is only created, rendered, and hydrated when the condition is true (i.e., when the modal should actually be shown). Combined with the
- The
This way, your modal is only loaded, rendered, and hydrated when it is actually needed. If you always render
Lazy prefix and conditional rendering with v-if is subtle but important in Nuxt:
- Lazy prefix (e.g., <LazyRegisterModal />):This tells Nuxt to code-split the component and only load its JavaScript when the component is rendered for the first time. However, if you always include
<LazyRegisterModal /> in your layout or template, it will still be rendered (and hydrated) on every page load, even if the modal is not visible to the user yet. The Lazy prefix helps with initial bundle size, but not with runtime rendering or hydration cost if the component is always present in the DOM [Nuxt 3 Lazy Component Prefix].
- Conditional rendering with v-if (e.g., <LazyRegisterModal v-if="uiStore.isRegisterModalOpen" />):This ensures that the modal component is only created, rendered, and hydrated when the condition is true (i.e., when the modal should actually be shown). Combined with the
Lazy prefix, this means the component is only loaded, rendered, and hydrated when needed, and not before [Nuxt Docs: Delayed Hydration].
In summary:- The
Lazy prefix alone only defers loading the component's code.
- Using v-if ensures the component is not even rendered or hydrated until needed.
- For best efficiency, use both together:This way, your modal is only loaded, rendered, and hydrated when it is actually needed. If you always render
<UModal v-model="uiStore.isRegisterModalOpen" /> inside your modal component, but the modal component itself is always present in the DOM, you still pay the hydration cost for that component on every page load. Using v-if at the parent level avoids this [Nuxt Docs: Delayed Hydration].
Let me know if you want more details on delayed hydration strategies!
----------------------
Note: you can ask me a follow up question by @ mentioning me again :speech_balloon:
----------------------<@679734274840330384> Kapa.ai is still learning and improving, please let me know how I did by reacting below.
@kapa.ai so i should keep my v-model inside the individual components but also have the v-if in my layout where i load the modals?
Let me check the knowledge base for you again. One moment! :books:
----------------------
Yes, your understanding is correct. You should:
- Use
v-if in your layout or top-level component to conditionally render the modal component only when it is needed (e.g., when the relevant Pinia store state is true).
- Keep the v-model (or equivalent state binding) inside the individual modal component to control its open/close state.
This approach ensures that:
- The modal component is only loaded, rendered, and hydrated when it is actually needed, especially if you use the Lazy prefix (e.g., <LazyRegisterModal v-if="uiStore.isRegisterModalOpen" />).
- The internal logic and state management of the modal (such as v-model for open/close) remain encapsulated within the modal component itself.
This pattern is recommended for performance and efficiency, as it avoids unnecessary hydration and rendering of modals that are not visible or needed at the moment [Nuxt Docs: Delayed Hydration].
If you need more advanced control, you can also explore Nuxt's delayed hydration strategies for even finer optimization.
----------------------
Note: you can ask me a follow up question by @ mentioning me again :speech_balloon:
----------------------<@679734274840330384> Kapa.ai is still learning and improving, please let me know how I did by reacting below.