usemage query edit and app consistency with the versions working without error
Hello,
Thank you for this beautiful app and tool that we can utilize our projects.
I'd like to ask about the usemage query, why can't we edit or give/add additional tasks to the query. Also, how do we make sure that our app is consistent with the version we implemented the task and coming updates/upgrades.
Thank you.
6 Replies
Hi @ysnshn. I'm kapa.ai, your friendly support bot. I will try to answer your question by searching through the knowledge base. :wave:
----------------------
Thank you for your kind words and your questions!
1. Editing or Adding Tasks to a Query
If by "usemage query" you mean Wasp's
useQuery hook (which is used to fetch data reactively in your React components), it's important to note that queries in Wasp are designed for reading data, not for directly editing or adding tasks. To modify data (such as adding or editing tasks), you should use Actions, not Queries. Actions are specifically meant for changing data, while Queries are for fetching it. This separation ensures a clear and predictable data flow in your app Docs: Operations Overview.
When you perform an Action (like creating or updating a task), Wasp automatically invalidates the relevant Query caches. This means that after you add or edit a task via an Action, the associated Queries (e.g., fetching the list of tasks) will automatically refetch and update, keeping your UI in sync without manual intervention Docs: Cache Invalidation.
If you want to optimistically update the UI (show changes before the server confirms them), you can use the useAction hook with optimistic updates. This allows you to update the Query cache manually for a better user experience Docs: Optimistic Updates.
2. App Consistency with Versions and Updates
Wasp aims to keep your app consistent by automatically managing Query invalidation and cache updates when you use Actions and Queries as intended. However, regarding consistency across Wasp versions and future updates:
- Wasp does not currently provide a built-in mechanism for ensuring backward compatibility or automatic migration between different Wasp versions.
- To maintain consistency, it's recommended to regularly check the Wasp documentation and release notes for any breaking changes or upgrade instructions.
- When updating Wasp or your dependencies, thoroughly test your app to ensure that all features work as expected with the new version.
If you are concerned about automatic Query invalidation being too aggressive or not flexible enough, Wasp is planning to provide more control over this in the future. For now, you can use the lower-level APIs from react-query for advanced scenarios Docs: Cache Invalidation.
If you need more specific versioning or migration strategies, the current knowledge sources do not provide detailed guidance on this topic.
---
If you have a more specific scenario or error regarding "usemage query," please clarify, and I'll do my best to help!
----------------------
Note: you can ask me a follow up question by @ mentioning me again :speech_balloon:
----------------------
Sorry @ysnshn, I seem to be having a bit of trouble. Don't worry though, I've pinged my support and they will try to fix me up! :technologist:
Perhaps try again in 15mins?@kapa.ai By "usemage" they mean the Mage tool. Please answer their question according to that:
I'd like to ask about the usemage query, why can't we edit or give/add additional tasks to the query. Also, how do we make sure that our app is consistent with the version we implemented the task and coming updates/upgrades.
Let me check the knowledge base for you again. One moment! :books:
----------------------
Thank you for clarifying that you are referring to the Mage tool (Wasp AI).
Editing or Adding Tasks to Mage-Generated Queries
Currently, Mage (the AI code generator for Wasp) has several limitations:
- You cannot directly edit or add additional tasks to the queries generated by Mage through the Mage interface itself. Mage is designed to generate an initial version of your app, including entities, pages, queries, and actions, based on your description. However, it does not support interactive editing or incremental updates to specific queries or tasks after the initial generation. If you want to make changes, you need to manually edit the generated Wasp code yourself after Mage has created the initial version of your app. This is a known limitation, and Mage is best used as a starting point or idea generator, not as a full-featured app editor or maintainer Discord: Mage limitations.
- There are also restrictions in Mage regarding adding new files, dependencies, or using advanced Wasp features. These limitations are in place to keep the generated code simple and manageable, but they also mean you have to take over manual development for more complex needs GitHub: Mage limitations.
Ensuring App Consistency with Wasp/Mage Versions
- Mage does not currently provide any built-in mechanism to ensure that your app remains consistent with the version of Wasp or Mage used to generate it. The generated code is a starting point, and as you continue development, you are responsible for maintaining and updating your app as Wasp evolves.
- To keep your app consistent and compatible with future Wasp updates, it is recommended to:
- Regularly check the Wasp documentation and release notes for breaking changes or upgrade instructions.
- Test your app thoroughly after upgrading Wasp or any dependencies.
- Consider using tools like Aider for further development and codebase management, as suggested by the Wasp community Discord: Mage and Aider.
Mage is intended to help you kickstart your app, but manual intervention and maintenance are expected as you move forward with your project. The Wasp team is aware of these limitations and may improve Mage in the future, but there is no specific roadmap or timeline for these features yet GitHub: Mage limitations.
If you have more specific needs or run into issues, the Wasp Discord is a good place to ask for help and share feedback.
----------------------
Note: you can ask me a follow up question by @ mentioning me again :speech_balloon:
----------------------
Sorry @Carlos, I seem to be having a bit of trouble. Don't worry though, I've pinged my support and they will try to fix me up! :technologist:
Perhaps try again in 15mins?
@ysnshn The bot gave a good overview, is that useful?
thank you for asking, no actually, I had asked about the usemage.com, the query text is not editable and cannot be updated it seems, I asked about that
can you send a screenshot? I'm not sure what you're referring to