hi, live-input's current state isn't getting updated when user stops streaming WebRTC (WHIP/WHEP). t

hi, live-input's current state isn't getting updated when user stops streaming WebRTC (WHIP/WHEP). this just recently started happening.
this keeps returning true.

isConnected: json.result.status?.current?.state === 'connected'

isConnected: json.result.status?.current?.state === 'connected'

isConnected: json.result.status?.current?.state === 'connected'

isConnected: json.result.status?.current?.state === 'connected'

this is the endpoint we're calling:
https://api.cloudflare.com/client/v4/accounts/accountId/stream/live_inputs/input.inputId

GGagan Suie hi, live-input's current state isn't getting updated when user stops streaming W...

tt2468•5/4/24, 10:00 PM

Are you calling DELETE on the WHIP resource url at the end of the publish session?

Ttt2468 Are you calling DELETE on the WHIP resource url at the end of the publish sessio...

Gagan SuieOP•5/4/24, 10:04 PM

no i am not. i didn't have to do that before.

Gagan SuieOP•5/4/24, 10:04 PM

ill give it a shot

Lukee•5/4/24, 10:55 PM

Hey! I've just started using cloudflare stream. On videos, I can restrict embedding to specific URLs, but I can't see a way to do this with live streams. Anyone know if this is possible?

Ttt2468 Are you calling DELETE on the WHIP resource url at the end of the publish sessio...

Gagan SuieOP•5/4/24, 11:21 PM

Doesn't live-input status get auto set to disconnected if there's no data coming through?

GGagan Suie Doesn't live-input status get auto set to disconnected if there's no data coming...

tt2468•5/4/24, 11:34 PM

Only after a timeout. If you arent sending DELETE, it is breaking whip spec

Gagan SuieOP•5/5/24, 12:31 AM

im getting a 405 Method not allowed on the endpoint im using to view the video which im getting from json.result.webRTC.urljson.result.webRTC.url

Gagan SuieOP•5/5/24, 12:34 AM

@renan
https://community.cloudflare.com/t/maximum-time-for-a-live-input/352251/2

getting this issue. Inputs its timing out

S4GR•5/6/24, 6:05 AM

sometimes video segments take 3+ seconds to respond on seek while using HLS, can anyone explain why this is happening?

Erin•5/6/24, 10:32 PM

hey folks, is there a way to play multiple streams sequentially, like a playlist?

Erin•5/6/24, 10:35 PM

our use case, we're building a fitness app and each workout has stations and each station has exercises. We'd like to upload a video per exercise but those the user just one video with all those "stitched" together (or sequentially)

OTO!!•5/7/24, 9:14 AM

Hello, guys.
I want to upload the large video using TUS.
What is the maximum size of video that can be uploaded?
is it possible to upload 20GB?
Thanks is advance.

szef0•5/8/24, 2:07 PM

Hello, we are building a big video shopping mobile app. ~200k users - how excatly does the streaming pricing work? When I just start to watch the video its already a minute streamed? We were just testing and its already 700 minutes - I know it can be a little bit of a pricing question, but maybe someone has expierience with it

whoami•5/9/24, 8:30 PM

Hello, if I want to use WebRTC, I have a question about the connection with OBS, whether I can use media source?

GGagan Suie hi, live-input's current state isn't getting updated when user stops streaming W...

Ale•5/10/24, 3:27 AM

Instead of constantly calling the API, use websocket instead. Here you have the url to check the current status of the stream
wss://live-status.videodelivery.net/websocket/source/${streamKey}/status

AAle Instead of constantly calling the API, use websocket instead. Here you have the ...

Ale•5/10/24, 3:29 AM

You can use the streamKey of the protocol you most want (RTMPS, SRT WHIP) they will all respond to the state of the stream

Gagan SuieOP•5/10/24, 3:33 AM

We're using webhooks because then it hits our servers. Using websockets makes the process dependent on a client.

Gagan SuieOP•5/10/24, 3:34 AM

This way, users can add restream urls and use obs without using our platform everytime (just setup once). And viewers can view the video on our platform or twitch or youtube.

GGagan Suie This way, users can add restream urls and use obs without using our platform eve...

Ale•5/10/24, 3:36 AM

I got your point

Ale•5/10/24, 3:37 AM

How can I know the number of minutes served for a stream?

Gagan SuieOP•5/10/24, 3:37 AM

We originally used websockets actually. Just not that url you provided.

AAle How can I know the number of minutes served for a stream?

Gagan SuieOP•5/10/24, 3:39 AM

In our platform we use Webhook connected and webhook disconnected events to create start and stop timestamps.

GGagan Suie In our platform we use Webhook connected and webhook disconnected events to crea...

Ale•5/10/24, 3:40 AM

dare to do the calculation yourself

Gagan SuieOP•5/10/24, 3:41 AM

It's triggered by cloudflare webhooks. We just save the timestamps when those events hit.

GGagan Suie It's triggered by cloudflare webhooks. We just save the timestamps when those ev...

Ale•5/10/24, 4:03 AM

I've been doing this for a month and I'm still green on some things. Example if I do not have any output defined for a stream nor record the stream and a client starts a transmission from the obs, cloudflare counts those minutes to me

Ale•5/10/24, 4:05 AM

My intention is to block access to a user who has expired or exceeded their plan, without having to delete that stream.

Gagan SuieOP•5/10/24, 4:09 AM

are you setting the timestamps when webhooks hit?

GGagan Suie are you setting the timestamps when webhooks hit?

Ale•5/10/24, 4:17 AM

No, I still don't

Gagan SuieOP•5/10/24, 4:19 AM

you're using webrtc or rtmps?

Gagan SuieOP•5/10/24, 4:20 AM

sorry actually it wouldn't matter, they both timeout as soon as they stop receiving data

Ale•5/10/24, 4:48 AM

I am granting the client access to all protocols, but I want to be able to deny service.

khalil•5/13/24, 6:19 AM

Is there any builtin protections preventing malicious/ddos views racking up stream minutes/bill? Can someone just write a script that opens a thousand streams?

khalil•5/13/24, 6:26 AM

perhaps views are tied to ip?

Rrenan yep! check this out for the most control, including IPs: https://developers.clou...

khalil•5/14/24, 8:56 AM

ah, I am aware of signed urls and geo/ip restriction, but I am concerned that might not be enough.
For example, if a logged-in user with access to the signed url in a non-blocked geo/ip region opens a bunch of streams at once, that could result in a large bill? Even if I time-limit the signed url, its still possible spam a bunch of stream fetches.

Is there any protection in which even if a bad actor passes the signed url, timelimit, and geo/ip checks, writing a shell script to open/download a stream 10000 times gets detected & blocked simply because the usage is suspicious (maybe in the simpler case of all requests coming from one ip)?

Jonathan•5/17/24, 4:58 PM

Hi all, I was wondering if there were any betas or updates on cloudflare stream WebRTC supporting playing using HLS or DASH? Also, are there any updates on the other limitations while in beta? (Recording, simulcasting, live viewer counts, analytics, and rtmp/srt in)

landon•5/20/24, 2:40 PM

im getting two strange errors:

When trying to do a direct creator upload of a video with smaller videos (so far tested and succeded with images less than 200mb) it works fine. Doing that same upload with a video of around 300mb eventually the connection just dies and get an NS_ERROR_GENERATE_FAILURE. Doing it with a video around 500mb gives me an immediate CORS origin error. Same domain same algoritm, only difference is video sizes as far as i can tell.
When trying to retrieve this thumbnail, https://customer-56fx8oxwdrk14ngj.cloudflarestream.com/38d41d8da5c940ed8208c7d63831207e/thumbnails/thumbnail.jpg it hangs and returns a 524 error eventually

Llandon im getting two strange errors: 1. When trying to do a direct creator upload of ...

landon•5/20/24, 2:42 PM

well, the thumbnail returning the 524 now resolves, didn't do anything

Llandon im getting two strange errors: 1. When trying to do a direct creator upload of ...

kingmesal•5/20/24, 5:26 PM

I have this same experience....

kingmesal•5/20/24, 5:27 PM

I'm trying to add 2 webhooks for my video streams ... When I run the command to add second webhook it overwrites the first...

is there a reason why i'm not allowed to have two webhooks?

Gagan SuieOP•5/21/24, 10:29 PM

Some of our live-inputs in our streaming platform aren't stopping. This is one example:

https://mage.stream/channel/78

Mage - A collaborative streaming platform

Mage is a collaborative streaming platform for gamers and developers