I was also wondering about this new effect. It seems like its a G effect or an AoA effect. When I st

I was also wondering about this new effect. It seems like its a G effect or an AoA effect. When I stick back into a turn at high G and AoA the stick pushes forward. So I'm fighting it and I'm getting an oscillation effect. Its really cool. But, would like to tone it down a bit. even with periodic effect at 12%, its really heavy.

JIGGAwestOP•8/20/23, 4:54 AM

to give context I updated to the most recent TelemFFB

Jaeger•8/20/23, 5:00 AM

You can eddid the effects in the Telem ini file. I would recommend to see into the user (?) ini, because this settings carry over from version to version while the ini gets reset (can't remember the correct file names, away from the computer). Just check in the TelemFFB channel down low. (knowledge base)

Firaga•8/20/23, 5:37 AM

I also got very intense and gradually worsening oscillations with the newest configurator & TelemFFB. So intense that had no other choice than to push the red button. My hypothesis is that some of the oscillations resonate if there is many or certain periodic effects overlapping. I did not have this issue when periodic effects were turned off. Also no problem with the "release version" of TelemFFB.

Firaga•8/20/23, 5:40 AM

I was worried that if I hold the stick, it will break the mounting points.

walmis•8/20/23, 5:44 AM

Did you run it with telemFFB with G/or AoA effects ?

Firaga•8/20/23, 5:46 AM

AoA, RPM, gun shake. I believe all of them might have triggered at the same time. Was really pushing AH-64 to test the new version. No G-effect.

walmis•8/20/23, 5:47 AM

Can you also show your settings? Periodics shouldn't cause such oscillations

Firaga•8/20/23, 5:49 AM

It did it with the default settings with latest wip-version of TelemFFB, master gain 100% and periodic gain 25%. No problem after turning some of the periodic effects down or off.

Firaga•8/20/23, 5:52 AM

No problem in this sense that it can be easily fixed by tuning down some settings. But some kind of periodic effect filtering or damping option could help if the oscillations start to shake too violently.

FFiraga No problem in this sense that it can be easily fixed by tuning down some setting...

walmis•8/20/23, 5:53 AM

Can you still screenshot the your vpconf settings effects/settings with advanced expanded ?

Wwalmis Can you still screenshot the your vpconf settings effects/settings with advanced...

Firaga•8/20/23, 5:54 AM

On mobile at the moment but can share later today once in front of the computer.

Wwalmis Can you still screenshot the your vpconf settings effects/settings with advanced...

Firaga•8/20/23, 7:37 AM

Here are my settings. Static force to counter offset extension. Friciton is not on despite the slider being at max setting.

Firaga•8/20/23, 7:39 AM

The oscillation (when it happens) starts with small but sharp vibration that gradually becomes more intensive, until it gets out of control. It is only coming with the latest TelemFFB. Not without it and not with an older version.

walmis•8/20/23, 7:39 AM

I've tweaked the Apache in the latest telemFFB, probably the ETL shake was causing this

walmis•8/20/23, 7:40 AM

Also set the Periodic Effect LPF to something like 20-30Hz

Wwalmis Also set the Periodic Effect LPF to something like 20-30Hz

Firaga•8/20/23, 7:40 AM

What does it do?

walmis•8/20/23, 7:41 AM

Attenuates the high frequencies

walmis•8/20/23, 7:41 AM

Can you expand the Advanced sections too ?

Wwalmis Can you expand the Advanced sections too ?

Firaga•8/20/23, 7:42 AM

Sorry for my ignorance but where is it?

Edit: Nevermind, found it.

Firaga•8/20/23, 7:45 AM

Did not touch the advanced settings so they should be defaults

walmis•8/20/23, 7:58 AM

you can set spring filter to 15Hz, should give more stability

Wwalmis you can set spring filter to 15Hz, should give more stability

Firaga•8/20/23, 8:03 AM

Not sure if I understand this correctly. The tooltip is telling that lower value means sluggish movement but less oscillations. 15 Hz is quite much higher than what I have now

walmis•8/20/23, 8:04 AM

Yeah, might need to update the tooltips

walmis•8/20/23, 8:05 AM

It's kinda more complicated, but I've found higher freqs give more stability

Firaga•8/20/23, 8:06 AM

Ok. I try to change one parameter at a time to see whether it makes a difference. Otherwise difficult to isolate the issue.

SaiRacing•8/20/23, 10:53 AM

Hi, looking in the FAQ there are several choices of FFB motors I noticed that the Rhino uses the lowest torque motor. I understand that it is multiplied though a gear so the force generated at the grip is higher than the stated spec.

My experience of FFB is mostly from simracing, and over there there has been a trend towards higher torque motors and direct drive (so no gear or belt-driven ffb). The more powerful motors allow for better 'feel' in the wheel because the responsiveness is better with the higher peak torque.

So I guess my question is if there are similar reasons to increase motor torque for flight sim sticks. The car use case is one I'm familiar with since I work with racecars irl but I've never flown a helicopter or warbird so I don't know what stick forces are like and if high peak forces are even required.

For reference, entry level ffb wheels range from 5-7nm and the high end DD wheelbases have peak torques of upto 25nm.

JJIGGAwest I was also wondering about this new effect. It seems like its a G effect or an A...

Number481•8/20/23, 11:17 AM

the effect (in TelemFFB) is called 'aoa reduction') and it should only be enabled on the F18 by default (as that is the specific aircraft it was developed to emulate)...

You can change the characteristics with these values (but you would want to edit the ones under the F18 section)
(ignore the typo in the description line

)

AndyHill•8/20/23, 11:18 AM

stick forces can be significant in warbirds and quite notable in jets

AndyHill•8/20/23, 11:18 AM

apparently in some situations and specific planes you might be pulling with all your might to get a warbird out of a dive

AndyHill•8/20/23, 11:22 AM

how do those heavy duty steering wheels handle cooling?

AAndyHill stick forces can be significant in warbirds and quite notable in jets

Jaeger•8/20/23, 11:23 AM

Which brings our plastic sticks on the edge of destruction

AndyHill•8/20/23, 11:24 AM

mine is metal, though

AndyHill•8/20/23, 11:25 AM

although I don't think it could take very heavy loads

NNumber481 the effect (in TelemFFB) is called 'aoa reduction') and it *should* only be enab...

JIGGAwestOP•8/20/23, 2:40 PM

I was flying the F15e and the mosquito they were both doing it. I haven't tried any other aircraft, I might assume everything is doing it.

JJIGGAwest I was flying the F15e and the mosquito they were both doing it. I haven't tried ...

Number481•8/20/23, 2:45 PM

ahh.. OK.. the original description sounded more like the aoa effect (which is based on AoA).. But that would be the g-loading effect...

NNumber481 ahh.. OK.. the original description sounded more like the aoa effect (which is b...

JIGGAwestOP•8/20/23, 2:54 PM

geforce_effect_enable is that just 1 for on and 0 for off? Or is there a global intensity ?

JJIGGAwest geforce_effect_enable is that just 1 for on and 0 for off? Or is there a global...

Number481•8/20/23, 2:59 PM

responded in #VPforce-TelemFFB

AAndyHill apparently in some situations and specific planes you might be pulling with all ...

mechsicko•8/20/23, 4:17 PM

Most cool passively with their gigantic heatsink motor casings the size of a watermelon. Completely impractical and unnecessary for a flight stick. Even if you want huge forces for some god forsaken reason just use bigger motors/belt ratio.

Simracing wheels need to do extremely high freq effects to simulate the vibrate-y feel of rubber meeting road and sharp effects like slamming curbs or landing from jumps etc with enough overhead to also generate the main forces without clipping so need to be very powerful to be able to do this convincingly, particularly with DD that lacks any mechanical advantage like gearing/belts. Aircraft have much lower freq forces so don't need the brute force simracing req and if you need high forces belt reduction does this with a lot less wasted space and money.

AndyHill•8/20/23, 5:45 PM

well iirc the f-18 stick was supposed to have something like 15kg max pull force so we're still some ways off even if we forget the sometimes completely freezing controls of some warbirds

AndyHill•8/20/23, 5:46 PM

and yeah it's a good point that the huge torque is for the effects in the steering wheels, I hadn't thought of that

AndyHill•8/20/23, 5:47 PM

the thing with ffb flight controllers is that they need to keep going flat out for extended periods of time

AndyHill•8/20/23, 5:48 PM

I guess it might help some that a steering wheel can make do with one motor, whereas a flight controller typically needs double the amount

Jon (Bounty_V)•8/20/23, 5:49 PM

direct drive ftw

Jon (Bounty_V)•8/20/23, 5:49 PM

Maybe gen 2 rhino will use a more powerful set of motors

AndyHill•8/20/23, 5:49 PM

dibs on the gen 2 rhino

AndyHill•8/20/23, 5:49 PM

or elephant or whatever

Jon (Bounty_V)•8/20/23, 5:50 PM

definitely needs to be named after another protected animal

Jon (Bounty_V)•8/20/23, 5:50 PM

Could call it the Meg

AndyHill•8/20/23, 5:50 PM

and heavily poached one

AndyHill•8/20/23, 5:51 PM

having a swat team ambush you at the post office is an integral part of the experience

I was also wondering about this new effect. It seems like its a G effect or an AoA effect. When I st

Similar Threads